Schedule your own 30 minute free consultation directly into our calendar
In what Circumstances is Will Construction Necessary?
When several executors are named, they typically file for Probate together. If any are deceased or choose not to apply, the others proceed, providing the court with reasons for the incomplete application.
English words often carry a range of meanings. During daily interactions, we imply and deduce meanings from the language we use—whether spoken, read, or written.
This aspect is especially pronounced in text, as readers lack the advantage of vocal tones or body language to guide their understanding.
Typical scenarios that necessitate the interpretation of wills include:
- Instances where the testator is acquainted with multiple individuals sharing the same name.
- Situations involving incorrect spelling of a name, or the use of a former name for someone who has since changed their name.
- Cases where a charitable organization is mentioned informally rather than by its official legal designation, or when the organization’s name has undergone changes.
- Circumstances where there’s ambiguity about whether specific items such as cars, jewellery, art pieces, or collectibles fall under categories like “personal belongings” or “domestic goods”.
- Occasions where phrases like “my estate” are employed, which could ambiguously refer to land, personal assets, or movable items, depending on context.
- When it’s not clear which property is being indicated by a phrase such as “my house.”
Deciphering the intent behind a will’s language can be challenging, even with guiding principles.
These principles may sometimes appear to conflict, leaving ample scope for debate. Disagreements often arise over what constitutes a “necessary” implication or when it’s appropriate to consult external evidence to resolve vague terms.
In the 1922 the High Court formulated the 10 principles of Will construction as determined in the matter of Fell v Fell, see below.
The 10 Principles of Will Construction
- The interpretation of a will should be based solely on its language. External or extrinsic evidence, such as statements made outside the Will, can only be used to clarify ambiguities in the text, not to introduce new elements.
- The language of the Will should be understood in its common usage. In cases of inconsistency, the entire will should be considered to resolve the meaning.
- A bequest may be recognised by the court even without explicit gifting language if the Will’s context necessitates it to fulfill the testator’s expressed wishes.
- Inferences can only be drawn by the court if the Will’s language, viewed in its entirety, clearly indicates an intention.
- The court cannot enforce an unclear intention; it can only deduce a “necessary implication” if the Will’s language is otherwise nonsensical.
- Should the Will’s wording inadvertently contain or lack certain words, the court is empowered to amend the text to honour the evident intent of the entire will.
- Implied terms that are essential for the will’s effectiveness may be included to prevent the will from being void and causing intestacy.
- When multiple interpretations of a phrase are possible, the court will favour the one that upholds the will’s validity.
- Mistakes that are apparent from the will’s language are considered part of the will and are important for its interpretation.
- Intestacy is deemed a measure of last resort; it is assumed that the will’s creator did not wish to die without a valid will.
Regrettably, the final interpretation of a will’s meaning is a matter for the courts. Consensus among those involved is not always achievable. Moreover, an executor may risk legal action for negligence by a disinherited beneficiary if they fail to obtain judicial clarification.
For considered, competent advice, contact the team at Champion Contested Wills today!
Important Notice
This article is provided for general interest and informational purposes only. It contains general information and is not tailored to individual circumstances. It does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Always seek the advice of a qualified legal practitioner for specific legal advice tailored to your needs and circumstances. While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information at the time of writing, applicable laws may change.
Liability limited by a Scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.
Copyright © 2024 Author Champion Contested Wills
Talk To Us Today
Let us help you create your Legacy your way or let us champion your cause. Book your free 30-minute telephone consultation today, or just call our Director on 0481 523 372 between 7am and 10pm (Monday to Friday) or email at info@championcontestedwills.com.au
For our Edgecliff and Parramatta offices 02 8324 7512 between 8am and 6pm (Monday to Friday)
For Queensland call 1300 229 180 between 8am and 6pm (Monday to Friday)